Our substitute life

The essence of the basic human problem is that we live a substitute life. From our basic human need for protection, security, and comfort, we’ve fabricated a whole maze of constructs and strategies to avoid being with our life as it is. And as a consequence of believing in this substitute life we are disconnected from awareness of our true nature, our naturally open heart.

Our substitute life is made of many different constructs: our identities, our self-images, our concepts of what life is, our opinions and judgments, our expectations, our requirements. All these we take as reality. As a consequence of these tightly held beliefs, we develop certain habitual behavioral strategies to deal with life as we interpret it.

All these strategies are based on core decisions that we made early on, about who we are and what our life is about. They are decisions we made to help us cope with the many inevitable pains of growing up.

Ezra Bayda

The monsters that scare us

It is striking how much of our life is tinged with fear. We all have fears inside ourselves, monsters and dragons that raise their heads from time to time. When they show themselves we can default to a smaller, less competent version of ourselves and feel that we are not capable of achieving anything.

However, as Rilke’s extraordinary text tells us, when we turn towards our fears many of them dissolve. The things that frightens us can actually help us grow. Running from them ultimately is running from a place of real grace. That which is most alien will become our friend. The very difficulties become our path of growth.

We, however are not prisoners. No traps or snares are set about us, and there is nothing which should intimidate or worry us. We are set down in life as in the element to which we best correspond. We have no reason to mistrust our world, for it is not against us. Has it terrors, they are our terrors; has it abysses, those abysses belong to us; are dangers at hand, we must try to love them. And if we could only arrange our life according to that principle which counsels us that we must always hold to the difficult, then that which now seems to us the most alien will become what we most trust and find most faithful. How should we be able to forget those ancient myths that are at the beginning of all peoples, the myths about dragons that at the last moment turn into princesses; perhaps all the dragons in our lives are princesses who are only waiting to see us once beautiful and brave. Perhaps everything terrible is in its deepest being something helpless that wants help from us.

Trying to become something

Practice is based on a complete acceptance of ourselves, as we are, balanced with a gentle, non-judging movement to change aspects of our behaviour which lead to unhappiness. Any desire for change comes within the framework of that non-judgmental acceptance, and an ease with the status quo.

We know when we are far from that. We can feel an urgency in our desire to change, a leaning forward that is tinged with fear. There can be all sorts of reasons for this, such as an fundamental lack of acceptance of ourselves. Or we have an “indirect acceptance“,  when we can only see good in ourselves if someone outside approves us. Or we get mixed up between been needed and being loved. Whatever the reason,  we can look to mediation to fix us, and it becomes attached to an outcome, ultimately adding to our unhappiness with ourselves. The reality of our lives is that we are three-steps-forward-two-steps-back-kinda-people, and need to accept ourselves as that.

Ajahn Sumedho encourages an awareness of what we call “the becoming tendency”, meaning the use of meditation to become something. You do this to get that. It’s a kind of busy-ness and doing-ness and leaning — taking hold of a method, or others’ ideas, or quick  solutions in order to get somewhere. This habit is the cause of many of our troubles, and can so easily take over our meditation. It can permeate the whole effort of spiritual practice. Indeed, he states that the becoming tendency can take over and gets legitimized by being called “meditation.”

Meanwhile, we miss the fact that we are losing the main point and that what we are doing has turned into a self-based program. We get caught in the illusion, trying to make the self become something other. We can relax without switching off, and consequently we can enjoy the fruits of our work. This is what we mean by letting go of becoming and learning to be. If we’re too tense and eager to get to the other end, we’re bound to fall off the tight rope.

Ajahn Amaro

Trusting in goodness

Everything has to do with loving and not loving. Rumi

Sometimes we know things better when we get some moments of calm. We can sense things easier. We see that there is something profound in people, something that yearns. It is sometimes covered up by fear and defences. It can get hassled and rushed. But it is there. We do not necessarily know what to call it.  But that “something” is good.

You sense it on a quiet morning, sitting with a coffee, when thoughts about the meaning of this life come easy. And after thoughts the memories  come…… warm memories, about the goodness of people, their smile and the love that has been given to you in your life.

And you can trust. You sense that, somewhere,  beneath the daily routine, beyond the constant planning you engage in, goodness is slowly coming into being. Your sitting may be nothing more than getting out of the way and allowing that happen. You see that kindness and love is what you seek, and it is never far away.  You see this clearer as you get older.  It has been constant all your life. It is the same in those you love. And it comes closer and closer.

Developing a secure sense of self: 1

Being comfortable with our life as it is, does not just mean that we are ok with the external elements in our life, such as our job, where we live, our relationships.  It also means that we have some degree of comfort and security in our sense of self. The self can be understood as the system that organizes our experience. It consists of the sensations, feelings, thoughts, and attitudes we have toward ourself and towards the world.

Our emotional health is related to us having a cohesive, strong, balanced and joyful sense of self. When this is not so strong,  and we are constantly uncertain of ourselves, we may find that we are always looking for approval and the validation of others. We can get unduly knocked down by their criticism. In other words, when we feel we are disapproved of, we feel crushed, and when we are praised, we are on cloud nine. Our sense of value comes not from within ourselves, but is dependent on others. If we have a  dependent personality structure, we are incredibly quick at sensing what will please others and will do those things in order to gain  security. However, because our sense of self is reactive, we can find our moods changing constantly, as if blown by the wind.

On the other hand,  when we have a strong inner sense of self-cohesion we have confidence about the acceptability of our personality even when others are not around. We develop a sense of inner security,  and this inner resilience calms us in times of stress. We can bounce back from the inevitable wounds which are caused by temporary failures, rejections, and disappointments. When we are young this sense of self grows through a dependence on significant others, However, this dependence on others reduces as we develop and we find a secure base inside ourselves. In other words, we can regulate our emotions inside ourselves, without too strong a need for others. We are secure with ourselves. We are able to be psychologically alone.

Winnicott spoke of the development of this capacity to be alone. He said that as we develop as a child we receive love from our parents. This allows us to begin to feel secure within ourselves and crucially we internalize the  feelings of love which we receive from our parents. We incorporate the  sense of security, safety and confidence into our  body, mind, and psyche, so that, normally sometime around the age of four or so,  we have arrived at the psychological capacity to be alone.

Winnicott used a lovely image to illustrate this secure sense of self. He said that “therapy is completed when a child can play alone”. What he means,  is that the child is secure enough inside him or herself that it is content with his or her own company, by itself, regardless of the mood, actions or attentions of the parent. This is a key sign of growing confidence in the developing self but is crucial for us as adults also. We too need the contentment with ourselves that we can “play” alone, without needing to look over our shoulders to others for their validation.

Does meditation help in this? It does, but with certain cautions. It is clear that silent sitting  increases our capacity to be with ourselves. As I have said before, through it we learn to be with ourselves, allowing our fears arise and pass away without giving them undue space, because we are strengthening our contentment with ourselves.  We can develop our capacity to be at home in the silence. As Ajahn Sucitto wrote, in meditation it is “time to go home”, where we find our own space “bright and cheery”. Meditation helps us be with ourselves, in this moment, not always leaning forward. In the context of this reflection on our secure self, this means that we are not leaning onto other people for their presence; we are content with our own.

However, meditation can sometimes be used to run away from this work of strengthening our sense of self. As Jack Engler,  a psychotherapist and meditation practitioner,  said,  “You have to acquire a sense of self before you can lose a sense of self.” Thus meditation practice and psychological work need to progress hand-in-hand.  John Welwood* has written extensively in this area,  and reminds us that sometimes we can be attracted to “teachings about selflessness and ultimate states, which seem to provide a rationale for not dealing with [our] … own psychological wounding. In this way, [we]… use Eastern teachings to cover up … incapacity in the personal and interpersonal realm”. We can use the teachings as  an outside,  substitute family, and this can slow down the necessary work of developing the inner secure base which will anchor us through life.

So psychological work needs to proceed alongside spiritual work. What steps can we take to strengthen our sense of self? How can we develop this secure base? I will give some ideas in the next related post but just to start here with the first step, awareness. When young, we form mental representations or “Internal Working Models”  (i.e., expectations, beliefs, “rules” or “scripts” for behaving and thinking)  regarding relationships, based on our early caregiving experience. Getting to know those models by gently reflecting on our relationship patterns is a key to moving on, and to stop repeating patterns which just serve to strengthen our insecure self. In other words, understand your childhood insecurity and the force it still contains. Identify the pattern and the pain which manifests in the way you approach relationships now.

In the next post of this series I will look at other ways we can work on our inner securuity.

*John Welwood, “Embodying your realization: Psychological work in the service of Spiritual Development” www.johnwelwood.com/articles/Embodying.pdf


If it ain’t broke….

Some similar ideas to the post yesterday, taken from the excellent blog Medicine to live By!

It strikes me that for many of us, our “self-work” becomes a full time job and overtakes some of the rest of the naturalness of life.  I know because I have long been a “professional evolver,” one who is in constant analysis of myself and what this or that situation in life has taught me.  It’s taught me a lot, but when I get too stuck in “how to heal and perfect my own nature,” I become a white bread and mayonaise, boring, stiff version of my colorful, goofy, tender, insecure self–the one who’s a real human being.

I don’t know about you, but I find myself, far too often, responding to myself or to someone else in my life with these pre-digested strategies for wellness when the best medicine might be simply to go out and live fully and robustly, noticing the many dimensions of life and filtering a little less of ourselves.   Seeking the “proper experiences,” whether the best meditation training, the most inspiring yoga class, is not the right prescription for happiness if we’ve failed to use it to give us flexibility in life.

Malynn Utzinger, “The Tyranny of Self Help” www.doctormalynn.com