Adding on

The Second Arrow

Now a well-instructed person, when touched with a feeling of pain, does not sorrow, grieve, or lament, does not beat his breast of become distraught. So he feels one pain: physical, but not mental. Just as if they were to shoot a man with an arrow and, right afterward, did not shoot him with another one, so that he would feel the pain of only one arrow. In the same way, when touched with a feeling of pain, the well-instructed person does not sorrow, grieve, or lament, does not beat his breast or become distraught. He feels one pain: physical, but not mental

The Buddha, The Sallatha Sutta

It is hard to stick just with the direct experience of life – to “actually be where we are”, as Jon Kabat Zinn advises in this morning’s quote.  This is especially the case in moments of difficulty and doubt. And we do not have to go looking for these:  If we just wait around,  life will bring us enough moments to challenge us. These can give rise to difficult emotions of greater or lesser intensity, such as sadness, anger, fear, feeling lost or a sense of deficiency.  For as long as we are alive we will encounter such moments. Therefore, one of the most useful skills we can develop are ones to work with such events and the subsequent emotions.  The Buddha’s teaching, quoted above, is a useful strategy to practice. He distinguishes between the difficulties or pain we naturally feel in life, and the pain or suffering that we shape ourselves. For example,  someone may say something that hits a sensitive part of our life, or we may be late for a meeting because of traffic or even fall ill by picking up some virus that is doing the rounds. However, we may then increase our suffering by the way we add on or the way the experience  gives rise to negative thoughts about ourselves or how our life is going. In other words, the hassle or the pain is natural, but we create suffering by how we perceive the event and the physical sensations, how we judge them, and how we respond to them.

When something difficult happens to us, we have a tendency to commence a whole bunch of mental processes that can lead to more difficulties and create suffering — often thus adding more pain than there was originally. We find it hard to simply be with what is happening, of being in a gentle relationship with it. Instead, we don’t like it, and want to push it away by finding fault in ourselves or others, blaming, judging, and generally feeling sorry for ourselves. We are trying to develop the skill to be able to open up to these strong emotions without either letting them discharge themselves in blame or self-pity, or running away from them or distracting ourselves from them as is easy in today’s society. In doing this we just try to let the moment be, without adding. Because life is complex we will encounter many situations in which elements are not ours to control, or in which things happen without malicious intention. Paradoxically, sometimes it is right and appropriate just to be sad.

A definition of healing

File:Felix Pfeifer00.jpg

To be in relationship to what you are going through, to hold it, and, in some sense, to befriend it — that is where the healing or transformative power of the practice of mindfulness lies. When we can actually be where we are, not trying to find another state of mind, we discover deep internal resources we can make use of. Coming to terms with things as they are is my definition of healing…….It’s very healing to realize, if only for a moment here and a moment there, that you can be in a wiser relationship with your interior experience than just being driven by liking it or hating it.

Jon Kabat Zinn

photo Franziska bauer

Both-and

apples and oranges

So many of our troubles, personal and political, come from “either-or” thinking. For example, when I’m talking with a person who holds religious or political beliefs that differ from my own, either-or thinking can create a combative situation: “I’m right, so he/she is wrong. Therefore, my job is to win this argument by any means possible.” But ”both-and” thinking can lead to something much more creative: “Maybe I don’t have everything right, and maybe he/she doesn’t have everything wrong. Maybe both of us see part of the truth. If I speak and listen in that spirit, we both might learn something that will expand our understanding.”

Think of how much more civil and creative our conversations across lines of difference would be if we thought that way more often! We’d be working to create a container to hold our differences hospitably instead of trying to win an argument.

Of course, like everything human, this issue begins inside of us, in how we hold our own internal paradoxes. If we can’t hold our inner complexities as both-and instead of either-or, we can’t possibly extend that kind of hospitality to another person. Here’s an ancient truth about being human: we cannot give gifts to others that we are unable to give to ourselves! That’s why “inner work” done well is never selfish. Ultimately, it will benefit other people.

Parker Palmer, Holding Paradox

Dont Know Mind II

File:Blue mountains and forest.jpg

Who makes these changes?

I shoot and arrow right, it lands left

I ride after a deer and find myself

chased by a boar.

I plot to get what I want

and end up in prison.

I dig pits to trap others

and fall in myself.

I should be suspicious

of what I want.

Rumi

The secret ingredient of happiness

File:Zahncremes.jpg

The most prophetic thing Thomas Merton ever did was to say to a Louisville shopkeeper who asked him what brand of toothpaste he preferred, “I don’t care”. Merton was intrigued and troubled by the store clerk’s response. “He almost dropped dead” he wrote,  “I was supposed to feel strongly about Colgate or Pepsodent or something with five colours. And they all have a secret ingredient. But I didn’t care about the secret ingredient ….the worst thing you can do now is not care about these things”

This not-caring attitude is important to hold onto these days and still prophetic, because the ultimate goal of the marketer is to have us see consumer products not as mere things, but as keys to our identity.  Brands are marks that owners out on their property, often by painful means, and we are in perilous territory when our self-image, and even our self-worth, is founded on which brands and labels we can afford to purchase and display.

Kathleen Norris, The Secret Ingredient

Trying to make things correspond to our ideas

IMG_0678

When one composes one’s mind and looks inwards, there is a sense of coming to one point. If we are not caught in the thinking process, we can be aware of the here and now, the body, the breath, mental states, moods; we can allow everything to be what it is.  The attitude of many people is that there is always a need to change something. When we practise meditation with this idea of getting something, then even the word ‘meditation’, can bring up the reaction of: ‘There’s something I’ve got to do. If I’m in a bad mood I should get rid of that mood. I’ve got to concentrate my mind.’ If the mind’s scattered and we’re all over the place, ‘I should make it one-pointed; I’ve got to concentrate.’ And so we make meditation into hard work and there is a great deal of failure in it because we’re trying to control everything through these ideas.

[Instead]….Try looking inwards with an attitude of observing whatever is present. Just notice what kind of mood or feeling you are in. So now put yourself in this position of the Buddha – Buddho, the knower—not the judge — and just look.

Ajahn Sumedho, Developing an attitude toward meditation